AGATHANo gut feelings

FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew Prediction

Sunday, Oct 18, 2026, 5:00 PM ET, TQL Stadium, Cincinnati, Ohio

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

AGATHA'S PICKFC CincinnatiFC Cincinnati

FINAL

0020

Columbus CrewColumbus Crew
50%WIN CHANCEFC Cincinnati to WinLOST#1336 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 50%

Agatha's pick: FC Cincinnati to WinTHE VERDICT

Agatha's pick for FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew

FC Cincinnati. Agatha gave FC Cincinnati a 50% chance to win at TQL Stadium, Cincinnati, Ohio. It was Agatha's prediction for this match, sealed and graded like every pick.

Why Agatha picked FC Cincinnati

The game sits on Cincinnati's home ground at TQL Stadium, and the attack has the men to use it. Kevin Denkey has 17 goals and 5 assists in 26 appearances this season, and Evander has 13 assists in 25 appearances. Cincinnati beat Atlanta United FC 3-1 on Oct 10. Agatha has Cincinnati winning 4-2, a coin flip. The risk is the Crew's 2-1 win in the last meeting, on Jul 25, 2026.

TV: Apple TV

Final score: Columbus Crew 2, FC Cincinnati 0

SEALED ODDS
+155Betfair
CLOSING ODDS
+115Betfair, at the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
LOST -1.00uat the sealed price
GRADED
7:14 PM ETreceipt #1336

Match Center

Team12T
FC CincinnatiCIN000
Columbus CrewCLB112

Leaders

  • Evander (CIN): 6
  • Samuel Gidi (CIN): 80
  • Nick Hagglund (CIN): 13
  • Gonzalo Tapia (CLB): 1
  • Sean Zawadzki (CLB): 36
  • Andres Herrera (CLB): 11
CIN

Tale of the tape

CLB

FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew recent form

CIN 1-2-2 FC Cincinnati: last 5 matches

  1. L2-3NE Oct 14 New England Revolution, 2-3
  2. W3-1ATL Oct 10 Atlanta United FC, 3-1
  3. L1-3MTL Sep 26 CF Montreal, 1-3
  4. D2-2HOU Sep 19 Houston Dynamo FC, 2-2
  5. D3-3CLT Sep 12 Charlotte FC, 3-3

CLB 3-0-2 Columbus Crew: last 5 matches

  1. W3-1CLT Oct 14 Charlotte FC, 3-1
  2. L2-3ORL Oct 10 Orlando City SC, 2-3
  3. W2-1MIA Sep 27 Inter Miami CF, 2-1
  4. W2-0MTL Sep 19 CF Montreal, 2-0
  5. L0-1RBNY Sep 12 Red Bull New York, 0-1
Goals scored, last 5CIN 11CLB 9
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterCIN 12CLB 6

FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew head-to-head

WHY

Since Jul 25, 2026: Columbus Crew 1, FC Cincinnati 0

  1. Jul 25, 2026Columbus Crew 2-1

FC Cincinnati vs Columbus Crew line movement

MONEYLINE FC Cincinnati to win at Betfair

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (CIN)

-0.25

Total

3.5

Moneyline

CIN
+118
Draw
+290
CLB
+185

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (21 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (CIN) at FanDuel: opened -120, now +125
  • Spread (CIN) at BetOnline: opened -0.5, now 0
  • Total at BetMGM: opened 3.5, now 3.5

Up next

  1. Sat, Nov 21, 6:00 PM ETInter Miami CF vs Columbus Crew PredictionAgatha's call: Inter Miami CF to win, 57%
  2. Thu, Nov 19, 10:00 PM ETSeattle Sounders FC vs Real Salt Lake PredictionAgatha's call: Seattle Sounders FC to win, 44%
  3. Sat, Nov 21, 2:00 PM ETNew England Revolution vs Philadelphia Union PredictionAgatha's call: New England Revolution to win, 40%
  4. Sat, Nov 21, 4:00 PM ETFC Dallas vs Portland Timbers PredictionAgatha's call: FC Dallas to win, 54%