AGATHANo gut feelings

Red Bull New York vs Toronto FC Prediction

Saturday, Oct 17, 2026, 7:30 PM ET, Sports Illustrated Stadium, Harrison, New Jersey

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

AGATHA'S PICKRed Bull New YorkRed Bull New York

FINAL

0020

Toronto FCToronto FC
50%WIN CHANCERed Bull New York to WinLOST#1244 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 50%

Agatha's pick: Red Bull New York to WinTHE VERDICT

Agatha's pick for Red Bull New York vs Toronto FC

Red Bull New York. Agatha gave Red Bull New York a 50% chance to win at Sports Illustrated Stadium, Harrison, New Jersey. It was Agatha's prediction for this match, sealed and graded like every pick.

Why Agatha picked Red Bull New York

Red Bull New York plays at home. It beat San Diego FC 4-1 on Oct 10 and allowed 1.3 goals per match to Toronto's 2.2 over their last ten matches. Julian Hall has 11 goals and 5 assists in 28 appearances this season. Agatha has Red Bull New York winning 2-0, a coin flip. The risk is Toronto scored more goals per match than Red Bull New York over their last ten matches, 1.8 to 0.9.

TV: Apple TV

Final score: Toronto FC 2, Red Bull New York 0

SEALED ODDS
-1331xBet
CLOSING ODDS
-1441xBet, at the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
LOST -1.00uat the sealed price
GRADED
9:37 PM ETreceipt #1244

Match Center

Team12T
Red Bull New YorkRBNY000
Toronto FCTOR112

Leaders

  • Julian Hall (RBNY): 4
  • Julian Bazan (RBNY): 86
  • Julian Bazan (RBNY): 12
  • Niklas Dorsch (TOR): 2
  • Jonathan Osorio (TOR): 27
  • Jonathan Osorio (TOR): 15
RBNY

Tale of the tape

TOR

Red Bull New York vs Toronto FC recent form

WHY

RBNY 3-0-2 Red Bull New York: last 5 matches

  1. L1-2DC Oct 14 D.C. United, 1-2
  2. W4-1SD Oct 10 San Diego FC, 4-1
  3. L0-3STL Sep 30 St. Louis CITY SC, 0-3
  4. W1-0NYC Sep 18 New York City FC, 1-0
  5. W1-0CLB Sep 12 Columbus Crew, 1-0

TOR 1-1-3 Toronto FC: last 5 matches

  1. D3-3ORL Oct 14 Orlando City SC, 3-3
  2. W2-1MTL Oct 10 CF Montreal, 2-1
  3. L0-2NSH Sep 26 Nashville SC, 0-2
  4. L1-3STL Sep 19 St. Louis CITY SC, 1-3
  5. L0-3ORL Sep 12 Orlando City SC, 0-3
Goals scored, last 5RBNY 7TOR 6
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterRBNY 6TOR 12

Red Bull New York vs Toronto FC head-to-head

Since Mar 14, 2026: Red Bull New York 0, Toronto FC 0, 1 draw

  1. Mar 14, 2026Drew 1-1

Red Bull New York vs Toronto FC line movement

MONEYLINE Red Bull New York to win at 1xBet

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (RBNY)

-0.75

Total

3.5

Moneyline

RBNY
-154
Draw
+350
TOR
+290

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (24 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (RBNY) at FanDuel: opened +105, now -165
  • Spread (RBNY) at BetOnline: opened -0.5, now -1
  • Total at BetMGM: opened 3.5, now 3.5

Up next

  1. LIVEInter Miami CF vs Columbus Crew PredictionAgatha's call: Inter Miami CF to win, 57%
  2. Sun, Nov 22, 4:00 PM ETNashville SC vs FC Cincinnati PredictionAgatha's call: Nashville SC to win, 67%
  3. Sun, Nov 22, 6:30 PM ETChicago Fire FC vs Charlotte FC PredictionAgatha's call: Chicago Fire FC to win, 47%