AGATHANo gut feelings
John McCarthyRed Bull New York

SoccerMLSRed Bull New YorkGoalkeeper

John McCarthy

United StatesStats, career and match log

John McCarthy is an MLS goalkeeper for Red Bull New York and won the 2024 MLS Cup with the LA Galaxy.

119 MLS matches23 clean sheets

Updated

About John McCarthy

Born on July 4, 1992, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, John McCarthy is a goalkeeper for Red Bull New York in MLS and wears number 77. He played for Ocean City Nor'easters from 2011 to 2012, then for Reading United AC in 2013 and Rochester Rhinos in 2014.

Season by season119

119 matches: 112 regular season, 7 playoffs. Every MLS match in our records, newest season first.

SeasonTeamAppsStartsMinSavesGACSSave %
2025LA, RBNY12121,0803629055.4%
2024LA32322,88012748672.6%
2024 playoffs55450164280.0%
2023LAFC25252,2506931869.0%
2022LAFC119042066.7%
2022 playoffs10311050.0%
2021MIA13121,1403520263.6%
2020MIA887201910165.5%
2020 playoffs119013025.0%
2018PHI1190601100.0%
2017PHI887203413172.3%
2016PHI119043057.1%
2015PHI11119902118253.8%
Career11211110,0503551742167.1%
Career playoffs76543188269.2%

How he is doing nowThrough Oct 18

2025 season36 saves12 matches
Red Bull New York12-6-16W-D-L, 2026 regular season; 42 points
Last match3 saves3 goals against, Oct 18 at Columbus

Match log, 2025

DateOpponentResultMinSavesGACSCards
Oct 18at Columbus CrewL1-390330
May 18vs LAFCD2-290220
May 14at Philadelphia UnionL2-390630
May 10at Red Bull New YorkL0-790470
Show all 12 matches
May 4at Sporting Kansas CityL0-190010
Apr 27vs Portland TimbersL2-490240
Apr 19at Austin FCL0-190410
Apr 12vs Houston Dynamo FCD1-190210
Apr 5at Real Salt LakeL0-290020
Mar 29vs Orlando City SCL1-290220
Mar 22at Minnesota United FCD2-290820
Mar 16at Portland TimbersD1-190310

Match lines from MLS's own match stats.

Did you know?!

Winning the 2022 MLS Cup

McCarthy won the 2022 MLS Cup with LAFC, beating the Philadelphia Union 3-0 on penalties after a 3-3 draw in the final on November 5, 2022.

A clean sheet at San Jose

Playing for the LA Galaxy on Jun 29, 2024, McCarthy kept a clean sheet with 6 saves in a 3-0 win at the San Jose Earthquakes.

CareerPro since 2011

Ocean City Nor'easters2011 to 2012
Reading United AC2013
Rochester Rhinos2014
Philadelphia Union2015 to 2018 - 21 MLS matches
Inter Miami CF2020 to 2021 - 22 MLS matches
LAFC2022 to 2023 - 27 MLS matches
LA Galaxy2024 to 2025 - 48 MLS matches
Red Bull New York2025 to now - 1 MLS match
15years2011 to 2025
  1. 2015MLS debut3 saves in a 2-1 win vs New York City FC
  2. Nov 2022MLS CupLAFC 3, Philadelphia Union 3
  3. 2024Best match6 saves, a clean sheet at San Jose Earthquakes
  4. Dec 2024MLS CupLA Galaxy 2, Red Bull New York 1
  5. Oct 18, 2025Latest match3 saves at Columbus Crew

Championships

  • MLS Cup 2022Nov 5, 2022; LAFC 3-3 over the Philadelphia Union; 1 save
  • MLS Cup 2024Dec 7, 2024; LA Galaxy 2-1 over Red Bull New York; 4 saves

Playoffs

7 matches

18 saves, 2 clean sheets; MLS Cup Playoffs 2020, 2022 and 2024

Regular season

112 matches

355 saves, 21 clean sheets

First MLS match

Apr 11, 2015: 3 savesPhiladelphia Union 2, New York City FC 1

Latest match

Oct 18, 2025: 3 savesColumbus Crew 3, Red Bull New York 1

Most often against

The clubs he has faced most in MLS, with his teams' record (wins, draws, losses) and his line against each.

3-1-3his teams

His line: 18 saves, 2 clean sheets

Last met Apr 12, 2025

5-1-1his teams

His line: 24 saves, 3 clean sheets

Last met Nov 1, 2024

FC Dallas6 matches
3-0-3his teams

His line: 23 saves

Last met Jul 13, 2024

Sources and updates

Stats and scores come from Agatha's own records: MLS's own match stats and ESPN's match summaries.

Updated Nov 18, 2026, 7:57 AM ET. Results and form refresh after every match; biography facts are checked weekly.