AGATHANo gut feelings
Kevin O'TooleNew York City FC

SoccerMLSNew York City FCDefender

Kevin O'Toole

United StatesStats, career and match log

Kevin O'Toole is a left-footed defender for New York City FC in MLS and wears number 22.

117 MLS matches2 goals

Updated

About Kevin O'Toole

Born on December 14, 1998, in Montclair, New Jersey, United States, Kevin O'Toole plays for New York City FC. The defender made his MLS debut on Sep 17, 2022, playing 90 minutes in a 2-0 win against the New York Red Bulls. In the 2024 MLS regular season, O'Toole had 1 goal and 2 assists in 30 matches for New York City FC.

Season by season117

117 matches: 105 regular season, 12 playoffs. Every MLS match in our records, newest season first.

SeasonTeamAppsStartsMinGAShotsYCRC
2026NYC25181,73702730
2025NYC26221,89511971
2025 playoffs5542700220
2024NYC30282,391121810
2024 playoffs4435900520
2023NYC21121,19200830
2022NYC3327000200
2022 playoffs3327000210
Career105837,4852544141
Career playoffs12121,05600950

How he is doing nowThrough Nov 7

2026 season2 assists25 matches
New York City FC10-12-12W-D-L, 2026 regular season; 42 points
Last match90 minutes1 shot, Nov 7 at DC United

Match log, 2026

DateOpponentResultMinGAShotsCards
Nov 7at D.C. UnitedW1-090001
Oct 31vs CF MontrealD1-145000yellow card
Oct 28vs Atlanta United FCW2-190011
Oct 24at Orlando City SCD2-290000
Show all 25 matches
Oct 17vs LAFCD1-190000
Oct 14at Inter Miami CFL0-2sub33000
Oct 10at Chicago Fire FCL1-2sub45000
Sep 26at Atlanta United FCD2-2sub10000
Sep 12at Real Salt LakeW2-0sub10000yellow card
Sep 9vs New England RevolutionL1-290001
Sep 4vs Nashville SCD0-090000yellow card
Aug 29at Toronto FCD1-1sub27000
Aug 23at New England RevolutionD1-1sub22000
Aug 19at FC CincinnatiL1-275000
Aug 16vs Philadelphia UnionL2-3sub30000
Apr 25at CF MontrealL0-190000
Apr 22vs FC CincinnatiD4-490001
Apr 18vs Charlotte FCL1-290000
Apr 11at Vancouver WhitecapsL0-290000
Apr 4vs St. Louis CITY SCD1-190000
Mar 22vs Inter Miami CFL2-390010
Mar 14vs Colorado RapidsW3-190000
Mar 7vs Orlando City SCW5-090000
Mar 1at Philadelphia UnionW2-190002
Feb 22at LA GalaxyD1-190001

Match lines from MLS's own match stats. MLS credits up to two assists on a goal.

CareerMLS since 2022

New York City FC2022 to now - 117 MLS matches
  1. 2022MLS debutStarted a 2-0 win vs Red Bull New York
  2. 2024Best season1 goal, 2 assists in 30 matches
  3. 2025Best match1 goal vs Toronto FC
  4. Nov 7, 2026Latest match90 minutes at D.C. United

Playoffs

12 matches

MLS Cup Playoffs 2022, 2024 and 2025

Regular season

105 matches

2 goals, 5 assists

First MLS match

Sep 17, 2022: 90 minutesNew York City FC 2, Red Bull New York 0

Latest match

Nov 7, 2026: 90 minutesNew York City FC 1, D.C. United 0

Most often against

The clubs he has faced most in MLS, with his teams' record (wins, draws, losses) and his line against each.

1-4-4his teams

His line: 1 assist

Last met Oct 14, 2026

Sources and updates

Stats and scores come from Agatha's own records: MLS's own match stats and ESPN's match summaries.

Updated Nov 18, 2026, 7:51 AM ET. Results and form refresh after every match; biography facts are checked weekly.