AGATHANo gut feelings
Payton TolleBoston Red Sox

BaseballMLBBoston Red SoxStarting pitcher

Payton Tolle

Stats, career and game log

Payton Tolle is a left-handed starting pitcher for the Boston Red Sox and pitched an immaculate inning on September 13, 2026.

35 MLB games190 strikeouts

Updated

About Payton Tolle

Born on November 1, 2002, in Stillwater, Oklahoma, Payton Tolle pitches for the Boston Red Sox and wears number 70. The left-hander, who bats left-handed, made his MLB debut with the Red Sox on Aug 29, 2025. In the 2025 regular season he made 3 starts with a 6.06 ERA and 19 strikeouts in 16.1 innings. On September 13, 2026, he pitched an immaculate inning.

Season by season35

35 appearances: 33 regular season, 2 postseason. Every MLB appearance of his career, newest season first.

SeasonTeamGamesStartsIPKBBERAWHIP
2026BOS2626148.2171403.031.10
2026 postseason114.2411.931.29
2025BOS7316.11986.061.59
2025 postseason100.1000.000.00
Career3329165.0190483.331.15
Career postseason215.0411.801.20

How he is doing nowLast game Sep 29, 2026

2026 pitching3.03 ERA148.2 innings, 171 strikeouts, 1.10 WHIP
Red Sox87-752026 regular season, 0-2 in the playoffs
Last game4.2 IP, 4 K, 1 ERSep 29 at Yankees
Injury status

No injury reports on file.

Game log, 2026

BOS @ NYYFinal 0-9, Sep 29, 2026

IP 4.2, H 5, R 1, ER 1, BB 1, K 4, HR 0, PC-ST 83-58, ERA 1.93, PC 83

Betting: BOS moneyline lost, run line +1.5 did not cover

CLE @ BOSFinal 3-2, Sep 22, 2026

IP 5.2, H 8, R 2, ER 2, BB 2, K 5, HR 0, PC-ST 91-63, ERA 3.03, PC 91

Betting: BOS moneyline lost, run line -1.5 did not cover

KC @ BOSFinal 1-4, Sep 13, 2026

IP 6.0, H 4, R 0, ER 0, BB 1, K 7, HR 0, PC-ST 96-70, ERA 3.02, PC 96

Betting: BOS moneyline won, run line -1.5 covered

BOS @ BALFinal 3-1, Sep 6, 2026

IP 6.0, H 4, R 1, ER 1, BB 0, K 12, HR 0, PC-ST 91-70, ERA 3.15, PC 91

Betting: BOS moneyline won, run line -1.5 covered

Show all 8 games
SEA @ BOSFinal 8-9, Aug 31, 2026

IP 5.2, H 6, R 4, ER 4, BB 2, K 6, HR 1, PC-ST 96-64, ERA 3.23, PC 96

Betting: BOS moneyline won, run line -1.5 did not cover

BOS @ MIAFinal 7-3, Aug 25, 2026

IP 5.1, H 4, R 2, ER 2, BB 2, K 7, HR 1, PC-ST 97-62, ERA 3.09, PC 97

Betting: BOS moneyline won, run line -1.5 covered

ARI @ BOSFinal 7-6, Aug 19, 2026

IP 5.0, H 6, R 3, ER 3, BB 2, K 6, HR 0, PC-ST 98-68, ERA 3.08, PC 98

Betting: BOS moneyline lost, run line -1.5 did not cover

BOS @ TORFinal 7-0, Aug 13, 2026

IP 8.0, H 2, R 0, ER 0, BB 2, K 4, HR 0, PC-ST 91-61, ERA 2.97, PC 91

Betting: BOS moneyline won, run line -1.5 covered

Box score lines from ESPN.

Betting: his team's result at the closing moneyline and run line most of our sportsbooks closed at (3 books or more).

Did you know?!

A 14-strikeout start

On Aug 7, 2026, Tolle started and allowed 1 earned run on 2 hits over 6.0 innings, with 14 strikeouts in a 13-1 win against the Athletics.

CareerDebut 2025

1year2025 to 2026
  1. 2025MLB debut4-2 loss vs Pirates
  2. 2026Best start6.0 IP, 14 K, 1 ER, vs Athletics
  3. 2026Best season148.2 IP, 171 K, 3.03 ERA in 26 games
  4. Sep 29, 2026Latest game4.2 IP, 4 K, 1 ER at Yankees

Regular season

33 games

165.0 IP, 190 K, 3.33 ERA

Postseason

2 games

5.0 IP, 4 K, 1.80 ERA

Honors

  • Pitched an immaculate inning on September 13, 2026

First MLB game

Aug 29, 2025: 5.1 IP, 8 K, 2 ERPirates 4, Red Sox 2

Latest game

Sep 29, 2026: 4.2 IP, 4 K, 1 ERYankees 9, Red Sox 0

Most often against

The teams he has faced most, with his teams' record and his line against each.

Athletics4 games
2-2his teams

His line: 16.1 IP, 27 K, 2.76 ERA

Last met Aug 7, 2026

1-3his teams

His line: 18.0 IP, 22 K, 1.00 ERA

Last met Sep 29, 2026

2-2his teams

His line: 18.2 IP, 15 K, 3.38 ERA

Last met Aug 13, 2026

3-0his teams

His line: 17.2 IP, 26 K, 2.55 ERA

Last met Sep 6, 2026

0-3his teams

His line: 12.0 IP, 8 K, 4.50 ERA

Last met Jun 9, 2026

Sources and updates

Stats, scores and injury reports come from Agatha's own records: the SABR Lahman Baseball Database for the seasons through 2025, MLB's own box scores, its transactions and ESPN's injury reports.

Updated Nov 18, 2026, 7:45 AM ET. Results and form refresh after every game; biography facts are checked weekly.