AGATHANo gut feelings

Islanders vs Maple Leafs Prediction

Saturday, Oct 17, 2026, 7:00 PM ET, Scotiabank Arena, Toronto

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

New York IslandersAWAYNew YorkIslanders3-3-1

FINAL

0410

AGATHA'S PICKToronto Maple LeafsHOMETorontoMaple Leafs3-3-2
50%WIN CHANCEMaple Leafs to WinLOST#1237 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 50%

Agatha's pick: Maple Leafs to WinTHE VERDICT

Final score: Islanders 4, Maple Leafs 1

SEALED ODDS
-119BetUS
CLOSING ODDS
Same as sealedat the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
LOST -1.00uat the sealed price
GRADED
9:39 PM ETreceipt #1237

Game Center

Team123T
IslandersNYI1124
Maple LeafsTOR0011

Leaders

  • Colton Sissons (TOR): 1
  • Troy Stecher (TOR): 1
  • Colton Sissons (TOR): 1
  • Simon Holmstrom (NYI): 2
  • Bo Horvat (NYI): 1
  • Simon Holmstrom (NYI): 2

Play-by-play

  1. Game End
  2. End of 3rd Period
  3. End of 3rd Period
  4. P319:58Morgan Rielly Wrist Shot Wide Right
  5. P319:56Darren Raddysh Wrist Shot saved by Ilya Sorokin
  6. P319:03Jack Roslovic Wrist Shot saved by Ilya Sorokin
  7. P318:30Bo Horvat faceoff won against Jack Roslovic
  8. P318:30Icing
  9. P318:16Zack MacEwen hit Emil Heineman
  10. P318:15Teddy Blueger hit Matthew Schaefer
  11. P318:08Zack MacEwen hit Brayden Schenn
  12. P317:55Teddy Blueger faceoff won against Bo Horvat

Game-day injuries

NYITOR
  • Calum RitchieDay-To-Day
  • Matias MaccelliDay-To-Day
  • Mathew BarzalInjured Reserve
  • Alexander RomanovOut
  • John TavaresInjured Reserve
  • Dakota JoshuaInjured Reserve
  • Miles WoodInjured Reserve
  • Chris TanevInjured Reserve
  • Max DomiInjured Reserve

Agatha's pick for Islanders vs Maple Leafs

The Maple Leafs. Agatha gave Toronto a 50% chance to win at Scotiabank Arena, Toronto. It was Agatha's prediction for this game, sealed and graded like every pick.

Why Agatha picked the Maple Leafs

The Maple Leafs won the latest meeting, 2-1 at home on Sep 30, 2026, and the six meetings since Dec 31, 2024 are split 3-3. The Maple Leafs score 3.5 goals a game this season, the Islanders 2.9. Mathew Barzal, a center, is listed as Injured Reserve with a knee injury. Agatha has the Maple Leafs winning 4-3, about even. The risk is two losses in a row for the Maple Leafs, the latest 5-4 in overtime to the Buffalo Sabres at home.

TV: ESPN+

NYI

Tale of the tape

TOR

This season

Goals per gameWHYNYI 2.9TOR 3.5
Goals against per gamefewer is betterNYI 2.4TOR 3.5

Islanders vs Maple Leafs recent form

WHY
Goals scored, last 5NYI 13TOR 22
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterNYI 15TOR 21

Islanders vs Maple Leafs head-to-head

WHY

Since Feb 5, 2024: Islanders 5, Maple Leafs 3

  1. Sep 30, 2026Maple Leafs 2-1
  2. Apr 9, 2026Islanders 5-3
  3. Mar 17, 2026Islanders 3-1
  4. Jan 3, 2026Islanders 4-3
  5. Jan 2, 2025Maple Leafs 2-1
  6. Dec 31, 2024Maple Leafs 3-1
  7. Dec 21, 2024Islanders 6-3
  8. Feb 5, 2024Islanders 3-2

Islanders vs Maple Leafs line movement

MONEYLINE Maple Leafs to win at BetUS

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (TOR)

-1.5

Total

6

Moneyline

NYI
+110
TOR
-125

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (15 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (TOR) at FanDuel: opened -140, now -126
  • Spread (TOR) at FanDuel: opened -1.5, now -1.5
  • Total at FanDuel: opened 6.5, now 6.5

Up next

  1. Thu, Nov 19, 7:00 PM ETIslanders vs Jets PredictionAgatha's call: Winnipeg Jets to win, 52%
  2. Thu, Nov 19, 7:00 PM ETKings vs Maple Leafs PredictionAgatha's call: Toronto Maple Leafs to win, 51%
  3. Wed, Nov 18, 7:30 PM ETBruins vs Red Wings PredictionAgatha's call: Boston Bruins to win, 50%
  4. Wed, Nov 18, 7:30 PM ETCanadiens vs Devils PredictionAgatha's call: New Jersey Devils to win, 54%
  5. Wed, Nov 18, 10:00 PM ETAvalanche vs Mammoth PredictionAgatha's call: Colorado Avalanche to win, 57%