AGATHANo gut feelings

Rangers vs Blue Jackets Prediction

Saturday, Oct 17, 2026, 7:00 PM ET, Nationwide Arena, Columbus

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

New York RangersAWAYNew YorkRangers6-3-0

FINAL

0010

AGATHA'S PICKColumbus Blue JacketsHOMEColumbusBlue Jackets2-3-0
56%WIN CHANCEBlue Jackets to WinWON#1229 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 56%

Agatha's pick: Blue Jackets to WinTHE VERDICT

Agatha's pick for Rangers vs Blue Jackets

The Blue Jackets. Agatha gave Columbus a 56% chance to win at Nationwide Arena, Columbus. It was one of Agatha's Best NHL Bets for Oct 17.

Why Agatha picked the Blue Jackets

The Rangers are without their goalie Igor Shesterkin, who is on Injured Reserve with a knee injury, and Dylan Garand starts in net in his place. The Blue Jackets won the latest meeting 6-3 at home on Mar 19, 2026. Zach Werenski had 22 goals, 59 assists and 81 points in 75 games last season, and Kirill Marchenko had 27 goals, 40 assists and 67 points in 76 games. Agatha's prediction is a 4-2 Blue Jackets win, a little better than a coin flip. The risk is the Blue Jackets have lost two games in a row, and the Rangers allow fewer goals per game, 2.3 to 4.2.

TV: ESPN+

Final score: Blue Jackets 1, Rangers 0

SEALED ODDS
-130Pinnacle
CLOSING ODDS
Same as sealedat the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
WON +0.77uat the sealed price
GRADED
10:01 PM ETreceipt #1229

Game Center

Team1234T
RangersNYR00000
Blue JacketsCBJ00011

Leaders

  • Kent Johnson (CBJ): 1
  • Charlie Coyle (CBJ): 1
  • Kent Johnson (CBJ): 1

Play-by-play

  1. Game End
  2. End of OT
  3. OT3:26Kent Johnson Goal (4) Wrist Shot, assists: Zach Werenski (5), Charlie Coyle (6)
  4. OT2:11Alexis Lafreniere shot blocked by Zach Werenski
  5. OT1:34Takeaway by Sean Monahan
  6. OT1:27J.T. Miller faceoff won against Sean Monahan
  7. OT1:27Goalie Stopped
  8. OT1:26Sean Monahan Wrist Shot saved by Dylan Garand
  9. OT1:05Charlie Coyle Tip-In Wide Left
  10. OT0:33J.T. Miller faceoff won against Adam Fantilli
  11. OT0:33Goalie Stopped
  12. OT0:30Kent Johnson Wrist Shot saved by Dylan Garand

Game-day injuries

NYRCBJ
  • Igor ShesterkinInjured Reserve
  • Joe VelenoInjured Reserve
  • Joonas KorpisaloInjured Reserve
  • Aidan ThompsonInjured Reserve
  • Adam SykoraInjured Reserve
    NYR

    Tale of the tape

    CBJ

    This season

    Goals per gameWHYNYR 3.1CBJ 3.2
    Goals against per gamefewer is betterNYR 2.3CBJ 4.2

    Rangers vs Blue Jackets recent form

    WHY
    Goals scored, last 5NYR 17CBJ 16
    Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterNYR 15CBJ 21

    Rangers vs Blue Jackets head-to-head

    WHY

    Since Feb 28, 2024: Rangers 5, Blue Jackets 3

    1. Mar 19, 2026Blue Jackets 6-3
    2. Mar 2, 2026Blue Jackets 5-4
    3. Nov 15, 2025Rangers 2-1
    4. Mar 15, 2025Rangers 4-0
    5. Mar 9, 2025Blue Jackets 7-3
    6. Feb 8, 2025Rangers 4-3
    7. Jan 18, 2025Rangers 1-0
    8. Feb 28, 2024Rangers 4-1

    Rangers vs Blue Jackets line movement

    MONEYLINE Blue Jackets to win at Pinnacle

    Market (latest pregame line)

    Spread (CBJ)

    -1.5

    Total

    6.5

    Moneyline

    NYR
    +116
    CBJ
    -132

    Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (9 snapshots)

    • Moneyline (CBJ) at FanDuel: opened -132, now -138
    • Spread (CBJ) at FanDuel: opened -1.5, now -1.5
    • Total at FanDuel: opened 6.5, now 6.5

    Up next

    1. Sun, Nov 22, 12:30 PM ETHurricanes vs Rangers PredictionAgatha's call: Carolina Hurricanes to win, 53%
    2. Sat, Nov 21, 7:00 PM ETBlue Jackets vs Maple Leafs PredictionAgatha's call: Columbus Blue Jackets to win, 51%
    3. Sat, Nov 21, 1:00 PM ETOilers vs Hurricanes PredictionAgatha's call: Carolina Hurricanes to win, 61%
    4. Sat, Nov 21, 3:30 PM ETBlackhawks vs Flames PredictionAgatha's call: Calgary Flames to win, 59%
    5. Sat, Nov 21, 6:00 PM ETSabres vs Panthers PredictionAgatha's call: Florida Panthers to win, 52%