AGATHANo gut feelings

Lightning vs Rangers Prediction

Tuesday, Oct 13, 2026, 7:15 PM ET, Madison Square Garden, New York

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

AGATHA'S PICKTampa Bay LightningAWAYTampa BayLightning4-1-0

FINAL

0140

New York RangersHOMENew YorkRangers5-2-0
54%WIN CHANCELightning to WinLOST#956 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 54%

Agatha's pick: Lightning to WinTHE VERDICT

Final score: Rangers 4, Lightning 1

SEALED ODDS
-154Betano
CLOSING ODDS
-167Betano, at the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
LOST -1.00uat the sealed price
GRADED
9:58 PM ETreceipt #956

Game Center

Team123T
LightningTBL1001
RangersNYR2114

Leaders

  • Alexis Lafreniere (NYR): 2
  • Tye Kartye (NYR): 2
  • Alexis Lafreniere (NYR): 2
  • Zemgus Girgensons (TB): 1
  • Pontus Holmberg (TB): 1
  • Zemgus Girgensons (TB): 1

Play-by-play

  1. Game End
  2. End of 3rd Period
  3. P319:31Zemgus Girgensons faceoff won against Cole Beaudoin
  4. P319:31High Stick
  5. P319:19Conor Geekie hit Sean Durzi
  6. P318:51Conor Geekie faceoff won against Noah Laba
  7. P318:51Icing
  8. P318:09Mika Zibanejad Wrist Shot saved by Andrei Vasilevskiy
  9. P317:49Mika Zibanejad faceoff won against Zemgus Girgensons
  10. P317:49Off-side
  11. P317:16Noah Laba faceoff won against Conor Geekie
  12. P317:16Mika Zibanejad Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: none

Game-day injuries

TBLNYR
  • Dennis HildebyOut
  • Yanni GourdeInjured Reserve
  • Igor ShesterkinInjured Reserve
  • Joe VelenoInjured Reserve
  • Joonas KorpisaloInjured Reserve
  • Aidan ThompsonInjured Reserve
  • Adam SykoraInjured Reserve

Agatha's pick for Lightning vs Rangers

The Lightning. Agatha gave Tampa Bay a 54% chance to win at Madison Square Garden, New York. It was Agatha's prediction for this game, sealed and graded like every pick.

Why Agatha picked the Lightning

The Tampa Bay Lightning have won four games in a row. Andrei Vasilevskiy posted a .912 save percentage over 58 starts last season, and Igor Shesterkin, a goalie for the Rangers, is listed as Injured Reserve with a knee injury. Nikita Kucherov had 44 goals, 86 assists and 130 points in 77 games for the Lightning last season. Agatha has the Lightning winning 3-2, slightly better than even. The risk is the Rangers won the latest meeting, 5-1 at home on Oct 1, 2026.

TV: ESPN+

TBL

Tale of the tape

NYR

This season

Goals per gameTBL 3.2NYR 3.3
Goals against per gamefewer is betterTBL 2.4NYR 1.9

Lightning vs Rangers recent form

WHY
Goals scored, last 5TBL 16NYR 18
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterTBL 12NYR 9

Lightning vs Rangers head-to-head

WHY

Since Mar 14, 2024: Lightning 4, Rangers 4

  1. Oct 1, 2026Rangers 5-1
  2. Apr 15, 2026Rangers 4-2
  3. Nov 29, 2025Lightning 4-1
  4. Nov 12, 2025Rangers 7-3
  5. Apr 17, 2025Rangers 4-0
  6. Apr 7, 2025Lightning 5-1
  7. Dec 28, 2024Lightning 6-2
  8. Mar 14, 2024Lightning 6-3

Lightning vs Rangers line movement

MONEYLINE Lightning to win at Betano

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (NYR)

+1.5

Total

5.5

Moneyline

TBL
-167
NYR
+140

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (11 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (NYR) at FanDuel: opened +134, now +134
  • Spread (NYR) at FanDuel: opened +1.5, now +1.5
  • Total at FanDuel: opened 5.5, now 5.5

Up next

  1. Thu, Nov 19, 7:30 PM ETOilers vs Lightning PredictionAgatha's call: Tampa Bay Lightning to win, 56%
  2. Sun, Nov 22, 12:30 PM ETHurricanes vs Rangers PredictionAgatha's call: Carolina Hurricanes to win, 54%
  3. Wed, Nov 18, 7:30 PM ETBruins vs Red Wings PredictionAgatha's call: Boston Bruins to win, 50%
  4. Wed, Nov 18, 7:30 PM ETCanadiens vs Devils PredictionAgatha's call: New Jersey Devils to win, 54%
  5. Wed, Nov 18, 10:00 PM ETAvalanche vs Mammoth PredictionAgatha's call: Colorado Avalanche to win, 57%