AGATHANo gut feelings

Sharks vs Maple Leafs Prediction

Monday, Oct 19, 2026, 7:30 PM ET, Scotiabank Arena, Toronto

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

San Jose SharksAWAYSan JoseSharks4-3-1

FINAL

0130

AGATHA'S PICKToronto Maple LeafsHOMETorontoMaple Leafs3-4-2
56%WIN CHANCEMaple Leafs to WinWON#1379 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 56%

Agatha's pick: Maple Leafs to WinTHE VERDICT

Agatha's pick for Sharks vs Maple Leafs

The Maple Leafs. Agatha gave Toronto a 56% chance to win at Scotiabank Arena, Toronto. It was one of Agatha's Best NHL Bets for Oct 19.

Why Agatha picked the Maple Leafs

The Maple Leafs score more goals a game than the Sharks this season, 3.2 to 2.8. William Nylander put up 30 goals, 49 assists and 79 points in 65 games last season, and Matthew Knies added 23 goals and 66 points. Joseph Woll had the higher save percentage of the two goalies last season, .899 to Yaroslav Askarov's .884. The game is at Scotiabank Arena, Toronto, the Maple Leafs' home ground. Agatha predicts a 5-3 Maple Leafs win, a little better than a coin flip. The risk is the Sharks won the latest meeting, 4-1 at home on Apr 2, 2026.

TV: ESPN+

Final score: Maple Leafs 3, Sharks 1

SEALED ODDS
-133Betano
CLOSING ODDS
-143Betano, at the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
WON +0.75uat the sealed price
GRADED
10:19 PM ETreceipt #1379

Game Center

Team123T
SharksSJS1001
Maple LeafsTOR0123

Leaders

  • Auston Matthews (TOR): 1
  • Auston Matthews (TOR): 2
  • Auston Matthews (TOR): 3
  • Mason Marchment (SJ): 1
  • Tyler Toffoli (SJ): 1
  • Mason Marchment (SJ): 1

Play-by-play

  1. Game End
  2. End of 3rd Period
  3. P319:50Collin Graf hit Morgan Rielly
  4. P319:33Zack MacEwen Wrist Shot saved by Yaroslav Askarov
  5. P319:25Teddy Blueger faceoff won against Michael Misa
  6. P319:25Puck in Benches
  7. P319:20Michael Misa faceoff won against Teddy Blueger
  8. P319:20Nick Paul Goal (2) Wrist Shot, assists: Auston Matthews (9), Colton Sissons (2)
  9. P319:07Macklin Celebrini shot blocked by Jake McCabe
  10. P319:02Dmitry Orlov Wrist Shot Wide Left
  11. P317:19Michael Kesselring Wrist Shot saved by Sergei Bobrovsky
  12. P317:16Takeaway by Michael Kesselring

Game-day injuries

SJSTOR
  • Quentin MustyInjured Reserve
  • Kyle KeyserInjured Reserve
  • John TavaresInjured Reserve
  • Dakota JoshuaInjured Reserve
  • Miles WoodInjured Reserve
  • Chris TanevInjured Reserve
  • Max DomiInjured Reserve
SJS

Tale of the tape

TOR

This season

Goals per gameWHYSJS 2.8TOR 3.2
Goals against per gamefewer is betterSJS 3.6TOR 3.6

Sharks vs Maple Leafs recent form

Goals scored, last 5SJS 13TOR 18
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterSJS 17TOR 21

Sharks vs Maple Leafs head-to-head

WHY

Since Jan 6, 2024: Sharks 4, Maple Leafs 2

  1. Apr 2, 2026Sharks 4-1
  2. Dec 11, 2025Sharks 3-2
  3. Mar 27, 2025Sharks 6-5
  4. Mar 3, 2025Sharks 3-2
  5. Jan 9, 2024Maple Leafs 7-1
  6. Jan 6, 2024Maple Leafs 4-1

Sharks vs Maple Leafs line movement

MONEYLINE Maple Leafs to win at Betano

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (TOR)

-1.5

Total

6.5

Moneyline

SJS
+122
TOR
-138

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (13 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (TOR) at FanDuel: opened -142, now -140
  • Spread (TOR) at FanDuel: opened -1.5, now -1.5
  • Total at FanDuel: opened 6.5, now 6.5

Up next

  1. Sat, Nov 21, 10:00 PM ETKraken vs Sharks PredictionAgatha's call: Seattle Kraken to win, 50%
  2. Sat, Nov 21, 7:00 PM ETBlue Jackets vs Maple Leafs PredictionAgatha's call: Columbus Blue Jackets to win, 51%
  3. Sat, Nov 21, 1:00 PM ETOilers vs Hurricanes PredictionAgatha's call: Carolina Hurricanes to win, 61%
  4. Sat, Nov 21, 3:30 PM ETBlackhawks vs Flames PredictionAgatha's call: Calgary Flames to win, 59%
  5. Sat, Nov 21, 6:00 PM ETSabres vs Panthers PredictionAgatha's call: Florida Panthers to win, 52%