AGATHANo gut feelings

Penguins vs Avalanche Prediction

Friday, Oct 16, 2026, 9:00 PM ET, Ball Arena, Denver

Agatha Research Desk, Updated

Pittsburgh PenguinsAWAYPittsburghPenguins3-3-1

FINAL

0250

AGATHA'S PICKColorado AvalancheHOMEColoradoAvalanche4-2-1
61%WIN CHANCEAvalanche to WinWON#1123 SEALED

Win chance at the seal 61%

Agatha's pick: Avalanche to WinTHE VERDICT

Agatha's pick for Penguins vs Avalanche

The Avalanche. Agatha gave Colorado a 61% chance to win at Ball Arena, Denver. It was one of Agatha's Best NHL Bets for Oct 16.

Why Agatha picked the Avalanche

The Avalanche won four of the six meetings since Oct 26, 2023, including the latest, 6-2 on the road on Mar 24, 2026. They also score more, 4.4 goals a game to the Penguins' 3.6 this season, and Nathan MacKinnon had 53 goals, 74 assists and 127 points in 80 games for the Avalanche last season. Agatha has the Avalanche winning 5-2, about a 6-in-10 chance. The risk is the Avalanche lost 3-2 in overtime to the Dallas Stars at home on Oct 14, and Nicolas Roy is out.

TV: ESPN+

Final score: Avalanche 5, Penguins 2

SEALED ODDS
-199Pinnacle
CLOSING ODDS
Same as sealedat the start
STAKE
1 unitflat, every pick
RESULT
WON +0.50uat the sealed price
GRADED
11:41 PM ETreceipt #1123

Game Center

Team123T
PenguinsPIT2002
AvalancheCOL1315

Leaders

  • Artturi Lehkonen (COL): 2
  • Nathan MacKinnon (COL): 3
  • Nathan MacKinnon (COL): 4
  • Evgeni Malkin (PIT): 1
  • Sidney Crosby (PIT): 1
  • Evgeni Malkin (PIT): 1

Play-by-play

  1. Game End
  2. End of 3rd Period
  3. P319:57Nazem Kadri shot blocked by Declan Carlile
  4. P319:54Nathan MacKinnon shot blocked by Declan Carlile
  5. P318:10Giveaway by Martin Necas
  6. P317:51Blake Lizotte faceoff won against Gabriel Landeskog
  7. P317:51TV Timeout
  8. P317:51Kris Letang Hooking against Parker Kelly
  9. P317:47Giveaway by Kris Letang
  10. P317:10Artturi Lehkonen Wrist Shot Wide Left
  11. P317:00Giveaway by Samuel Girard
  12. P316:56Josh Manson hit Ben Kindel

Game-day injuries

PITCOL
  • Egor ChinakhovOut
  • Trevor van RiemsdykInjured Reserve
  • Justin BrazeauInjured Reserve
  • Ryan GravesInjured Reserve
  • Zachary L'HeureuxOut
  • Nicolas RoyOut
  • Logan O'ConnorInjured Reserve
  • Georgii MerkulovInjured Reserve
PIT

Tale of the tape

COL

This season

Goals per gamePIT 3.6COL 4.4
Goals against per gamefewer is betterPIT 3.1COL 3.1

Penguins vs Avalanche recent form

WHY
Goals scored, last 5PIT 12COL 17
Goals allowed, last 5fewer is betterPIT 17COL 17

Penguins vs Avalanche head-to-head

WHY

Since Oct 26, 2023: Avalanche 4, Penguins 2

  1. Mar 24, 2026Avalanche 6-2
  2. Mar 16, 2026Penguins 7-2
  3. Mar 4, 2025Avalanche 4-1
  4. Dec 10, 2024Avalanche 6-2
  5. Mar 24, 2024Avalanche 5-4
  6. Oct 26, 2023Penguins 4-0

Penguins vs Avalanche line movement

MONEYLINE Avalanche to win at Pinnacle

Market (latest pregame line)

Spread (COL)

-1.5

Total

6.5

Moneyline

PIT
+165
COL
-204

Line movement, tracked by Agatha since first sighting (20 snapshots)

  • Moneyline (COL) at FanDuel: opened -225, now -210
  • Spread (COL) at FanDuel: opened -1.5, now -1.5
  • Total at FanDuel: opened 6.5, now 6.5

Up next

  1. Sat, Nov 21, 6:00 PM ETPenguins vs Predators PredictionAgatha's call: Nashville Predators to win, 59%
  2. Wed, Nov 25, 9:30 PM ETCanadiens vs Avalanche PredictionAgatha's call: Colorado Avalanche to win, 57%
  3. Sat, Nov 21, 1:00 PM ETOilers vs Hurricanes PredictionAgatha's call: Carolina Hurricanes to win, 61%
  4. Sat, Nov 21, 3:30 PM ETBlackhawks vs Flames PredictionAgatha's call: Calgary Flames to win, 59%
  5. Sat, Nov 21, 6:00 PM ETSabres vs Panthers PredictionAgatha's call: Florida Panthers to win, 52%